By Stephanie Xiang
For the first time since 2018, Lovett’s Upper School Choir is preparing to return to Carnegie Hall, one of the world’s most celebrated concert venues. On February 13, 2027, Honors Singers will take the stage alongside four other choirs in New York City, marking an exciting milestone in the program’s efforts to rebuild its traditions after the disruptions of COVID-19.
For senior Madison Robinson ’27, the performance will mean more than singing on a famous stage. After four years in Honors Singers, the trip will bring her high school choir experience full circle.
“New York was my first Lovett Trip, and now it will be my last,” Madison said.
Carnegie Hall is only one part of the Upper School Choir’s story. From the familiar melodies of Lessons and Carols to singing the national anthem at Homecoming, Lovett’s choral program brings students together through music, shared traditions, and experiences that extend far beyond the classroom.
Led by Upper School Choral Director Ms. Deborah Ulrich, the program currently consists of two ensembles: Men’s Chorus and Honors Singers. Men’s Chorus focuses on developing fundamental musical skills, while Honors Singers is an audition-based group featuring more challenging music, higher expectations, and a more extensive performance schedule. Ms. Ulrich also hopes to bring back Women’s Chorus next year.
Lovett has a longstanding tradition, supported by directors who have remained with the program for many years, allowing each to build upon the work of those before them. Ms. Ulrich, now in her 16th year at Lovett, said that the choir is rebuilding after COVID-19 disrupted rehearsals and caused some students to leave the program. Despite those challenges, Ms. Ulrich believes the choir’s greatest purpose extends far beyond musical excellence.
“If we can grow really as humans in this program,” Ms. Ulrich said, “students can learn collaboration, integrity, and the importance of working toward something greater than themselves.”
That philosophy shapes how Ms. Ulrich prepares students for performances. She begins selecting music in late spring, continues planning throughout the summer, and adjusts her choices after hearing students sing in August. Instead of choosing pieces based only on their current abilities, she considers how much they can improve over the semester, balancing music that offers quick success with more challenging pieces that require months of preparation.
“Our repertoire is our curriculum,” Ms. Ulrich said.
Yet mastering the notes is only part of the process. Ms. Ulrich believes building a close-knit community is essential to creating a successful choir, especially when students bring diverse musical backgrounds and levels of experience.
“If only the people with the most beautiful voices sang, we wouldn’t have a choir,” Ms. Ulrich said.
For junior Baer Shaifer ’28, who serves as chorus president, that sense of community comes from years of shared experiences. Having participated in Lovett’s chorus program for six years, he has seen how rehearsals and annual traditions bring students together. “The common denominator is that chorus and its traditions have been in our lives for years,” Baer said.
Although choir creates a strong sense of community, preparing for performance also requires dedication, patience, and the confidence to overcome personal challenges. Baer described the pressure of mastering music during the final rehearsals, while Madison said stage fright remains one of her biggest challenges. “I wouldn’t say that chorus has gotten rid of my stage fright,” Madison said, “but because all chorus students are required to do solo performances at the end of the year, I’ve learned how to perform even when I’m scared.”
Sophomore Sonul Mittal ’29 has experienced a different kind of growth. Since joining the chorus in sixth grade, she has become more comfortable communicating with others and performing onstage. “Choir has also helped me with stage confidence,” Sonul said. “I barely get nervous on stage anymore.”
The choir has already put that dedication into practice through several performances this fall. The ensemble sang the national anthem at Homecoming and performed “Gaelic Blessing” at Chapel, a piece Ms. Ulrich selected for its message of goodwill.
For Sonul, singing on the gym floor without risers created an unfamiliar experience. “I felt more nervous standing closer to everyone on the gym floor without risers, but the overall experience was fun!” she said. Baer also acknowledged the challenges of adjusting to new students and changes in performance spaces, including the loss of the community center. “I think we will find and navigate the learning curve in each future performance,” Baer said.
As the choir continues adjusting to these challenges, its members are preparing for one of their most anticipated annual traditions: Lessons and Carols at All Saints Episcopal Church. The program features nine musical pieces and four carols with descants.
For Ms. Ulrich, Lessons and Carols holds a special place in her experience as a choral director. Having served as both organist and conductor for the service, she considers it one of the most meaningful events of the year. Baer shared that his favorite choir memory comes from last year’s Lessons and Carols performance, when he had the opportunity to sing alongside friends who were graduating.
“Getting to share a final performance in that beautiful building with beautiful music was a moment I will remember forever,” Baer said.
Not every memorable choir experience happens on a traditional concert stage. Madison recalled a choral competition at Disney World during her junior year, where a judge encouraged singers to try unusual exercises, including skipping in a circle, jumping while holding hands, and even singing with their fingers in their mouths. “It was very unusual, but all of his tips helped us improve, and we had fun while learning,” Madison said.
Yet beyond the excitement of major performances, students say the choir’s most lasting impact may be the relationship formed along the way. Madison met one of her best friends through chorus, while Baer described friendships he expects to maintain long after graduation. Sonul has experienced a similar sense of belonging.
“It started as bonds that were specific to chorus only, but they’ve evolved beyond just the class,” Sonul said.
As Lovett’s Upper School Choir prepares for Carnegie Hall and the opportunities ahead, the program continues to build on its longstanding tradition while creating new memories for its members. For students, choir is about more than the music they perform. It is about discovering their voices, supporting one another, and finding a place where they belong.
“It’s a lot of commitment,” Sonul said, “but you meet so many new people and learn not only about music, but about yourself as well.”
